
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I love historical fiction, and Philippa Gregory is my favorite author, but while most of her books rate five stars, this one only got four from me, and I will get to the reasons why soon.
In the beginning of this book, Queen Mary has died and Protestant Elizabeth I has come to power. She faces a number of challenges, particularly the change from Catholicism to Protestantism and the fact that her country is bankrupt. Additionally, the French are threatening to invade Scotland. She must also rule in a country that experienced weak leadership from its first female ruler. Add to this her desires as a female, and the fact that she is expected to wed and produce an heir.
In the midst of this comes her childhood friend, Robert Dudley, tried and convicted as a traitor. Nevertheless, Dudley has ambitions of being King, and thus woos Elizabeth all while his own wife remains constant in her faith and her love. Will Dudley set aside his wife Amy and marry Elizabeth? Will his ambition get the better of him and alienate those who already know him as a traitor?
A few things bothered me as I was reading. All of a sudden, about halfway through the book, Elizabeth began calling her advisor by the word, "Spirit." It did not fit with all of her other dialogue. And also in about the middle of the book, a habit was noted over and over that she picked at her fingernails. These two things did not add to the characterization, and in fact, detracted from the realism.
Also, if you read up on the real Amy Dudley, you may find some particulars about her which weren't included in the novel and actually did add to the characterization and drama. And last, the novel just ended without resolving all of the conflicts and answering the questions I had as a reader. This is not typical of Gregory, so for these reasons, this book only earned four stars from me, which is actually still really great.
View all my reviews